The 2024 Quarterback Draft Class Is Already Insane:
Download the Gametime app ( and redeem code ANALYSIS for $20 off your first purchase (terms apply).
TWITTER:
INSTAGRAM:
Go to and use promo code FANALYSIS for Mando’s Holiday Bundles. They are a great deal for new and returning customers AND just for my followers, Mando is offering an extra $5 off plus Free US Shipping on orders over $30.
Download the Gametime app ( and redeem code ANALYSIS for $20 off your first purchase (terms apply).
SECOND CHANNEL:
Apple Podcast:
Spotify Podcast:
DISCORD:
TIKTOK:
Welcome to the Football Analysis Youtube channel! Subscribe for all NFL related content! Drop a like if you enjoyed the video as all support is very much appreciated! Thanks for watching!
#nfl #nflfootball #football #nfldraft #nfldraft #giants
source
What do you think the Giants should do? 🤔
The Giants are not a million miles away from the 9-7-1 team, because it was vastly overrated. All but one of their wins were by 8 points or less. Against the last place Redskins, they managed an 8 point win, with some help from the officials, and a tie. They had five one-score wins, which means that with six big plays by their opponents, they could have been 4-13. they beat Tennessee by 1, on a last second missed FG, and beat Jacksonville by 6, when Lawrence hit a receiver a hair short of the end zone on the final play, and benefited from Lamar Jackson & Aaron Rodgers fumbling on their final offensive plays of consecutive games. They got thumped by Detroit, in a game that was the difference between the Lions having a winning and losing record, and their only decisive win was against Indianapolis, who were circling the drain (the last time Jones would ever win a game in NJ). That season was a disaster that somehow produced a viable record, and then they got a playoff win against another team with a deceptive record (Minnesota winning by only a single score in 11 games, only decisively beating the two worst teams in their division to bookend the season; all four losses were by double digits).
All in all, it was an amazing series of lucky breaks, that the Giants paid for karmically, because had they ended up with the record they deserved, they'd have been picking in the top five, and after the epic humiliation of their shitty preparations for the QB carousel in midseason, Daboll would have been out the door, and maybe Schoen with him.
I've been watching this channel for a while and have a few suggestions:
1) Edit down your script. You could probably cut out a good 20%; often it sounds like you're repeating yourself to pad out content and reach a minimum word count.
2) Slow it down. It always sounds like you're trying to read your overly-wordy sentences in one breath.
3) Vary your speech. Currently it's very monotonous and we're being blasted with a rapid, overly long wall of speech that doesn't differ much in intonation; it's also lacking in the natural pauses and little breaks that a well-done narration includes.
Remember, your viewers don't have the script in front of them and not only do we need to hear the words, we also have to hold them in working memory to understand what it is you're saying. These three things will all help.
4) The "love you guys" at the end sounds very, very forced. Just thank me for liking and subscribing, don't make me cringe.
Real easy answer. Ownership has not adapted to the changes of the game. He kept hiring old football guys who refused to conform. Now he’s got a clueless GM
Until this team fixes the trenches on both sides of the ball, they'll continue to be a perennial bottom feeder and laughing stock of the NFL. The game is won/lost in the trenches, always has, always will.
Mate, George Pickens is a bigger diva than O'Dell Beckham Jr., and that's saying a LOT. I do not want Pickens as a Giant.
All starts with blocking. Can’t block the defense how you expect to move the ball.
Milroe is trash
Makes me sick to my stomach watching Barkley and Jaden daniels in those play off games
The Giants haven't had a fully functional Offensive line since 2010. By then, the running lanes dried up. That's when you normally begun drafting New linemen to shore up fatiguing veterans and use their experiences to help the New players… But they did Not Do It. Eventually the pass protection disappeared too… around 2014. Eli's uniforms became more and more Green… from grass stains… No good. Then the coaching carousel and scapegoating Eli… and more change (without bettering the team)… no line rebuild… QB, QB, QB… that's all the idiot talk. Without linemen who can control the line of scrimmage consistently and protect the pocket on the Offensive system… QB's don't matter. The great and honorable Patric Mahomes could Not do anything with this sqaud… their lack of discipline, effort are all evidence of bad culture and training and conditioning programs.
QB play cannot be elite with the worst lines in the NFL.
For 3 years we have regressed consistently under the Bean Counter Schoen and the nose up his Butt, Daboll. They are both full of shit pretenders. In Buffalo, Daboll got a lot of credit for what other staff created. Schoen is a bean counter… under a good GM is helpful. Schoen runs the team like fantasy football. 🤮 That shit doesn't work in the NFL. He shows no honor to his best players. What effect does that have on the locker room.
Fix both lines… 7 starters per side… minimum. And solid depth. Then… find your skill positions… with a line you'll have a good chance at being a championship team. Nothing else matters.
Hey Schoen… 🗣 Stop trading away our best players stupid!!! Williams, McKinney and Even Jones seeing your number two is a number 4 QB. 😮 You look like you are Sabotaging the NYG's organization. Why? Treat our players with both discipline and Honor! Make them Champions not pre-Madonnas in shiny suits… put them in navy blue men's warehouse duds until they get in the playoffs… Miss the playoffs… cheap suits… Grow those boys into successful men. 😐
The Giants drafted Saquon Barkley instead of Josh Allen then released Barkley instead of trading him when he was under contract. They released McKinney because they didn't want to pay him, but left themselves with 43 million in salary cap and it's unclear if they can spend this money productively. They passed on Micah Parsons because of character issues, and instead drafted Kadarius Toney, a totally undisciplined and irresponsible player. They renewed Daniel Jones contract ($160 million over four years), then released him for fear he would be injured and they'd be forced to honor the entire contract. Do other teams make these same ridiculous decisions?
There is nothing wrong with Robinson. He's a great player
Quarterback and Offensive line are the main focus of the 2025 NFL Draft for the New York Giants. Without winning the trenches you aren’t winning anything. First round = quarterback. Their second pick should be an offensive lineman. 3rd pick should a be a DB or DL.
It's simple. Start wearing the gray pants again.
Schoen is a s*hit show. A random dice roll or coin flip (or mentally diseased sheep) probably would have selected better draft and FA management 🙁
Ugh if they didn’t have two magical playoff runs they have been the worst teams In 25 years
I hated the wandale pick when we made it idk why anyone would take a 5’7 receiver that early
Nice job youngster !!! A+++
What do we think the Giants should do? How about don’t draft a QB that NO ONE thought had first round potential. Daniel Jones had no business ever being a starting QB in the NFL. That was the beginning of the end.
They need to draft Cam Ward and let Daboll do his thing..Ward has a plus arm.. he's athletic and creates second pockets..this video starts off well and misses the mark at the end.
I was with you up until Sam Darnold. Sam Darnold is going to get broke off this off season. Their are only two Qbs in this draft. The market is the market
Kinda funny how he said barring injury for george pickens. Then the next week ( which is now last week against the browns ) does go down with an injury. Hey football analysis guy you jinxed my guy hahaha
Joe Mara needs to hire a president of football operations and have them clean house and hire a whole new staff that can develop talent properly – including new scouts, development coaches, etc. Because when you're missing on that many 1st round picks it points to an organizational issue rather than a player one. Also will need to start fresh with a new GM and head coach.
It all leads to failed ownership
Very well explained… And yes I believe the the Giants should trade down in this draft to accumulate as many picks as possible and correctly study every player thoroughly. There’s 7 Rnds which makes 7 players and so They need to start studying players now. They have no time to waste!! Then again, hopefully Schoen and Daboll are gone…!!
The qb is not the issue. You could put Tom Brady back there in his prime and he wouldn’t be successful. The offensive line has to give the qb more time….its that simple. It’s crazy that people think a new qb will fix it.
Hope is not a strategy. Selling off and cutting is the solution. trading down is a groovy idea also since their player talent level is not that great. Drafting Carson Beck high in the second round A la Levis would be wise. I really hope no first round QB in the top 5 unless they get a trade down offer they like. Draft better, coach better, and play smarter would help out a lot.
I love it.
Tackle the like button and subscribe to the channel! These videos are great! 🤟🏻💀
This is by far the best breakdown I've heard of this disastrous Giants tenure
As a Steelers fan, I want to thank the Giants for not drafting George Pickens. We really appreciate it!!!
As an eagles fan I just wanna say HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHBAHAHABABABHAHA
Clearly Giants dont have a clue which are the good players and bad ones. Until they overhaul their scouting department this will continue to be the case. They are missing seems like every first round pick. They arent keepjng their good players and letting them walk for nothing. Management has to be better. Joe has to get better at this and willing to take the bumps of developing a young GM.
Very Well Done Video
You really want a brand-new GM and coach for the next draft? They'll barely know where the bathroom is and they're supposed to draft a new QB. Sounds like a terrible plan
I had such a problem with the wandale pick it made no sense we had a lot small wrs already
Excellent analysis. I especially like that you don't get into the "Giants could have or should have drafted" revisionist history nonsense.
I heard an interesting take from Mike Lombardi. He said that John Mara is too nice a man to really turn their internal personnel over. The Giants need someone from the outside to tell Mara the truth and gut the franchise – scouts, trainers, doctors – you name it. Everybody has to be on the same page with one solitary goal. The last time the Giants had a real outsider come in was George Young. He was given complete control and that worked out for over 30 years.
That said, the Giants need to move on from Schoen and Daboll. I had high hopes for them but it looks like Schoen may be in over his head and Daboll may not have the right demeanor to be a head coach. This rebuild will take time so please save the Bill Belichick return to the Giants takes. The question is who?
The Giants organization perished when they decide to go for the WEST COAST offense instead of following their program that was successful…… tough defense , running game and average QB .
Keep Daboll and Schoen for now. They got saddled with bad players like Daniel Jones and like you said, the process was good fr their drafts, they just hit some bad luck. Plus, the Giants haven't had good coaching or front office work since Coughlin left. Running Daboll and Schoen out before they had a chance to reall ybuild their own team only hurts their prospects among replacements.
I agree they shouldn't draft a QB just because there is one on the board. They would probably be better off trading down and building the o-line and defense. 2026 is suppsoed to be amuch better QB class. As long as they don't draft yet another Manning.
Giants Fans are saying "at least they aren't the Jets" and Jets fans saying "at least they aren't the Giants". Both franchises are terrible and there's little hope for the future.
Why fire a GM and HC when you haven't even yet them get the QB they wanted. The OWNER is the one that made that Giant Daniel Jones contract happen out of loyalty. Idc about the fucking bears we aren't the Bears. Give them at least 2 years with the new QB they want. Firing them only sets the team back as you even mention "who would wamt to come here after they both get fired".
The Giants arr bad because of the draft.. great analysis 👏🏽👏🏽
I mean the Jones contract was literally always structured as a 2+2, I'm sick of hearing this 160/4 narrative. Go actually look at the contract.
I disagree with the giants having a lot of holes on the team, really only missing boundary corners, a healthy oline, qb and a coach they are inspired to play for, they need to fire their staff but compared to the Raiders who have very little talent, the giants have a much better roster to play with
I was with you untill the lions comparison
The Giants biggest mistake of the past decade was selecting Saquon Barkley at #2 overall when they could have selected the highest rated QB (according to Mel Kiper Jr) of the draft in Josh Allen. To be fair, his sub 60% completion rate in college was a legitimate concern. But they knew they needed a QB as Eli was near the end. If they weren't sold on any of the QBs that year, trading down could have netted themselves a bunch of high value picks. But if they weren't sold on Allen (Or Darnold, Rosen, or Lamar Jackson who all went in round 1), how could they have possibly been sold on Daniel Jones?
I feel like you’re shouting a bit in this one
I think they will Cam Ward in draft you can’t have basis opinion have the giants not draft QB
I think Joe schon and Brain Daboll will not be fired because how much times we have to go through head coaches and GM 3 out of last four years
I'm planning on "rock bottom" for the Giants having a basement. 😑